Unpacking Frenchie's Sexuality in "The Boys" Season 4: A Deeper Dive Beyond the "Reveal"

It seems like every season of The Boys brings its own set of shockwaves, and Season 4 is no exception. For many, the burgeoning romantic connection between Serge, better known as Frenchie (Tomer Capone), and Colin (Elliot Knight) has sparked a surprising amount of discussion, bordering on shock. But here's the truth: Frenchie's journey has always been more nuanced than a simple label. While the on-screen development with Colin might be a focal point for some viewers this season, the groundwork for Frenchie's complex identity was laid long before. Let's explore why this "reveal" isn't quite as new as it seems and what it truly signifies for character representation.

Frenchie's Identity: A Consistent Thread Through the Series

For those who've been paying close attention, Frenchie's bisexuality has been hinted at, and even subtly confirmed, across previous seasons. The idea that his current relationship with Colin is a sudden, out-of-the-blue development simply doesn't hold water for long-time viewers. The show has consistently woven elements into his backstory and present actions that point towards his attraction to more than one gender. Remember Season 2? The series delved into Frenchie's past as a hired gun and criminal associate, particularly his intense relationship with Jay. While the exact nature of their connection was left open to interpretation, the emotional depth and the devastating impact of Jay's death on Frenchie suggested a bond that transcended mere friendship. The narrative surrounding Cherie, Jay, and Frenchie often hinted at a polyamorous dynamic, where romantic and sexual relationships could exist between multiple individuals. The show never explicitly stated it, but the subtext was palpable. Frenchie's affectionate references to Jay as "my Dorothy" further underscore the intimacy of their past. Beyond these deeper dives, smaller moments also contributed to the mosaic of Frenchie's identity. Who can forget the infamous bachelor party scene for Mother's Milk? Frenchie was the one advocating for a more inclusive selection of performers, demonstrating an awareness and openness that went beyond traditional norms. Even an earlier, seemingly platonic kiss with Hughie, intended as a congratulatory gesture, showcased a physical expressiveness that didn't shy away from intimacy. So, when Season 4 brings Colin into the picture, it's not about changing Frenchie's orientation; it's about bringing a previously hinted-at facet of his identity to the forefront with a more direct narrative focus.

The Power of Representation: Why Colin Matters

It's easy to get caught up in the "shock" or even disappointment some viewers express, especially those who were invested in the platonic, and at times romantically tinged, dynamic between Frenchie and Kimiko. Their bond is undoubtedly one of the most compelling relationships in The Boys, built on mutual understanding, shared trauma, and genuine affection. The decision for them to pursue a platonic co-worker relationship in Season 4, while perhaps bittersweet for some, allows both characters to grow and explore different avenues. Frenchie's connection with Colin represents a significant step forward for queer representation on a show known for its boundary-pushing content. It's crucial to acknowledge that characters don't need to "prove" their bisexuality through on-screen relationships with partners of multiple genders. However, for viewers who may see themselves reflected in Frenchie, a more explicit narrative can be incredibly powerful. It normalizes bisexuality, moving it from the realm of subtext to a clear, integral part of a beloved character's story. The show's approach to Frenchie and Colin's relationship feels genuine, not forced. It acknowledges the complexities, particularly the unresolved history between Frenchie and Colin's family, which adds a compelling layer of dramatic tension. This isn't just about a same-sex romance; it's about Frenchie navigating his past mistakes and building new connections, even with the shadow of his former life looming.

Addressing the "Haters" and the "Shipping" Culture

It's unfortunate, but not entirely surprising, that some reactions to Frenchie's relationship with Colin stem from homophobia. The simplistic, often aggressive, dismissal of a character's identity, particularly when it challenges preconceived notions, is a common issue. The idea that Frenchie was "made gay" in Season 4 ignores years of subtle storytelling and character development. Furthermore, the strong fan base that "ships" Frenchie and Kimiko is a testament to the chemistry and emotional resonance between those characters. It's completely valid for viewers to enjoy and root for that dynamic. However, it's also important to separate personal preferences from a character's narrative arc. The showrunners are building a complex universe with diverse characters, and allowing Frenchie to explore a romantic relationship with Colin doesn't diminish the significance of his connection with Kimiko; it expands the narrative possibilities. Ultimately, judging a character's journey requires patience and an open mind. As Season 4 unfolds, we'll likely see more layers of this relationship, and Frenchie's character as a whole, revealed.

Frenchie's Past: More Than Just Kimiko

The long-running storyline between Frenchie and Kimiko is, without a doubt, a cornerstone of his character development. He was the first person who truly broke through Kimiko's walls, and their shared experiences forged an unbreakable bond. The moments of tenderness, the near-kisses, and the deep emotional reliance they placed on each other created a powerful romantic tension. It's understandable why many fans would hope for that to blossom into a full-blown romance. However, to focus solely on Kimiko is to overlook the other significant relationships that have shaped Frenchie. His past as an escort, for instance, strongly implies a history of sexual and romantic encounters with a variety of people, including men. These elements, while not always in the spotlight, are integral to understanding the full scope of his experiences and attractions. When Frenchie chooses to turn himself in for past crimes in Episode 5, it's a pivotal moment that speaks to his desire for redemption and perhaps a more authentic self. His intimate relationship with Colin, while complex due to their intertwined past, offers him a space for connection and vulnerability that might be different from what he shared with Kimiko.

Beyond the Labels: The Essence of Frenchie

Frenchie is a character defined by his loyalty, his artistic spirit, his deep capacity for love and pain, and his struggle with past demons. His sexuality is a part of that tapestry, but it doesn't solely define him. The show's willingness to explore his bisexuality with nuance and depth, without making it the sole focus or a sensationalized plot point, is commendable. For those who might still be processing Frenchie's romantic developments, consider this: The Boys is a show that thrives on challenging expectations and presenting characters with multifaceted identities. Frenchie's journey with Colin is not an anomaly; it's a continuation of a character who has always been more complex than he initially appeared. It's an opportunity to celebrate representation that feels earned, authentic, and deeply integrated into the fabric of the narrative. As new episodes of The Boys continue to drop, Frenchie's story, in all its glorious complexity, promises to be one of the most compelling narratives to follow. It's a reminder that understanding a character, much like understanding oneself, is an ongoing process, rich with unexpected turns and profound discoveries.